The transition from primary to secondary school can be a difficult time for students. Young students have to deal with a new environment, an increase in the number of teacher relationships they need to form and an increased workload. Evidence suggests that the stress may lead to an initial reduction in grades and a more negative attitude to school.
Researchers recently explored how best to help students manage this transition. To help reduce any assessment bias, they ran a double-blind experiment, which is where the teachers implementing the intervention and the students receiving it are unaware if they are in the control or intervention group. In this study, the intervention group were given advice on how most struggle to fit in at first, how to engage in academic and social environments and they had confirmation that support was available. The students also had to reflect on how they would deal with hypothetical situations.
Students in the intervention group reported:
Higher levels of school trust
Social belonging
Lower levels of anxiety
The intervention group went on to receive higher grades overall, as well as less numbers of low grades (D’s and F’s).
Students in the intervention group had on average 12% fewer absences and 34% fewer behavioural referrals than those in the control group.
The transition from primary school to secondary school can feel especially daunting, as students at this age are already going through many physical and psychological changes. Other research suggests that this stress is magnified when joining a new school because of the increased work requirement; new, multiple teacher-student relationships and having to navigate larger buildings.
Several studies have found that the stress of starting secondary school often leads to an initial reduction in grades, decline in self-esteem and negative attitude towards teachers. One study suggested a potential route to navigating these challenges. Researchers from Columbia University and Stanford University tracked teenagers over two years and found evidence to suggest that a student’s mindset affected how well they managed these transitions. They found that those with a growth mindset (#5, #68) were more likely to get higher grades, take on learning goals, value effort and adopt positive coping strategies and were less likely to feel helpless than students with a fixed mindset.
Transitions from one stage of education to another have also been studied in older students moving from secondary school to university. One recent study found that key to managing this change was keeping a sense of perspective, maintaining good physical health, and creating/maintaining support networks.
Supporting students when they transition to secondary school should start when they are still in primary school. Previous research has found that taster days, giving out clear information to set expectations and using some of next year’s material in advance are all helpful strategies. Likewise, evidence from this study suggests that pre-empting and removing some of the taboo of their worries (which typically include how most students are concerned that they won’t fit in or how to behave) will help facilitate this transition.
Using hypothetical situations that students may have to deal with offers a good chance for teachers to get an insight into how their students are currently feeling. It also helps the students talk through and explore possible solutions which will help to normalise the new situation they find themselves in.